The Phoenix Network:
About  |  Advertise
Adult  |  Moonsigns  |  Band Guide  |  Blogs  |  In Pictures
On The Cheap  |  Restaurant Reviews

40 years of Boston (Phoenix) food

A long-time writer reflects on our city’s culinary history
By ROBERT NADEAU  |  November 15, 2006

Food and cultural historian Laura Shapiro likes to point out a certain week in 1963 when Julia Child first appeared on WGBH and Betty Friedan published The Feminine Mystique. The dates couldn’t have been much further apart in 1966 when Joyce Chen started her cooking show on WGBH, and a Boston University theater student published the first issues of what became the Boston Phoenix. In 1966, Boston wasn’t known as a particularly good restaurant town, outside of a few expensive places like Locke-Ober, Café Budapest, and the Ritz-Carlton dining room. The last two are gone, and Locke-Ober hangs on only because, after it excluded women from its main dining room for more than a century, it was rescued by Boston’s most famous female chef, Lydia Shire. In 1966, moreover, home cooking began and usually ended with Fannie Farmer, although some new ideas from Child and Chen were coming in via public television.

WONDER WOMAN: Julia Child appeared on WGBH in 1963. The rest is history.

But under the radar flew a whole different kind of restaurant and home cooking, appealing to a new generation of students and young professionals. The restaurants were inexpensive, ethnic, and bohemian. Such rooms, often mere storefronts with a dozen tables or fewer, were discussed in the pages of the Phoenix and its predecessors, and first joined our community of advertisers. Alt-weekly readers and writers might splurge at Maison Robert, the city’s finest French restaurant and a Julia Child favorite. But we frequented cheap Italian restaurants in the North End and such outposts of red-sauce value as Simeone’s in Cambridge. In an adventurous spirit, we might join the cult of computer hackers gathered over Peking ravioli at Joyce Chen’s Small Eating Place. A few people even ventured to Medford’s Peking on the Mystic for more of this new, spicy, and more-authentic Chinese food. Other gathering places included the handful of Greek and Lebanese restaurants downtown, in the South End, and Cambridge, like the old Athens Olympia and the original Red Fez. After midnight, you could get breakfast all night at a colorful spot in the central meat market called Mondo’s. (Mondo’s clientele of night-owl students, taxi drivers, artists, and prostitutes has never been reassembled, but its collection of amateur nude oil paintings was a precursor to the Museum of Bad Art.) Bars and luncheonettes with cheap comfort food were popular, such as the old Brookline Lunch in Central Square, which became a lefty political hangout, and the pre-punk Model Café in Allston. The English Tea Room at 29 Newbury Street had a certain flare, as did a hippy/Mexican restaurant in Harvard Square called El Diablo, and — upstairs from a Cambridge fish market — a barebones spot with paper plates and blackboard specials called Legal Sea Foods.

For a treat, Boston Phoenix readers sought out competing homemade-ice-cream parlors in Somerville. Boston has been an ice-cream region since the early-19th century, but the last 40 years have taken ice-cream mania to new levels. (This is one way Phoenix readers have always had fun with food: tasting something at the absolute top level of a basically inexpensive category. We may not wear $5000 watches, but we indulge in a high-end ice-cream cone after a modest meal, a super-premium bottle of beer with our burger, a superb silk scarf to accessorize our thrift-shop clothes.)

Home cooking was also seeing changes. For every dinner party featuring earnest reproductions of Child’s and Chen’s recipes, there were people going back to Asian basics with the Japanese-based macrobiotic diet, buying fresh figs and basil in North End markets, and reinventing the American food of their grandparents with added and unsuitable doses of whole-wheat flour, honey, and soy sauce.

The first food column in the Phoenix was a series of alternative-cooking stories about, well, alternative cooking. But the paper had already developed relationships with the small restaurants through its discount “BADAmericlub,” and also took on the sponsorship of a series of three Cheap Eats restaurant guidebooks. They included some of the better expensive restaurants but concentrated on cheap ethnic and family restaurants.

The second edition, in 1974, included a new restaurant on the Cambridge-Somerville line called Peasant Stock. Peasant Stock was based on French country cooking, filtered through Julia Child, but it was run on a cooperative principle in which different chefs cooked on different nights. The results were inconsistent but good enough to keep everyone interested. One person who cooked at Peasant Stock was R.D. Rosen, who in the mid 1970s became the first Phoenix weekly restaurant critic. One of the owners was Louisa Kasdon, who now covers restaurants for Phoenix sister publication Stuff@night magazine.

By the mid ’70s, Joyce Chen’s encouragement of Mandarin-Sichuan chefs from Taiwan and Hong Kong (and the 1965 immigration-reform bill that ended discrimination against Asian immigrants) had led to almost two dozen exciting Sichuan-style restaurants in Greater Boston. (You can still get the idea today at Chung Shin Yuan in Newton, or at Mary Chung’s or Changsho in Cambridge.)

1  |  2  |  3  |   next >
Related: A haute time, Rocca, Sorellina, More more >
  Topics: Features , Michael Dukakis, Culture and Lifestyle, Museum of Bad Art,  More more >
  • Share:
  • Share this entry with Facebook
  • Share this entry with Digg
  • Share this entry with Delicious
  • RSS feed
  • Email this article to a friend
  • Print this article
40 years of Boston (Phoenix) food
Great article, thanks! Brings back so many memories, like Mondo's after an all-night game of Risk in the BU dorms, discovering "real" Italian food at Simeone's, and the many, many great meals (and massive murals, only a trace of which remain today in its Dali incarnation) at Peasant Stock. Just one quibble: I grew up in Inman Square in the '50s, a block from the original Legal, which at that time was just a fish market with a takeout fish & chips counter. My recollection is that when they first opened up a dining room (which had not only paper plates and blackboard specials, but the then-revolutionary concept of a team waitstaff), it was next door to the fish market, not upstairs. And let me say as well that your reviews back then were a bible for me and many other nascent foodies! I still remember your pronouncement on the now-defunct El Phoenix Room: "Yes, some of the food comes from cans, but they're the RIGHT cans."
By Saltimbocca on 11/17/2006 at 11:14:41
40 years of Boston (Phoenix) food
Thanks for remembering Simeone's Italian American Restaurant. It is nice to know that my Dad's and Uncle's dreams, hard work and long hours were not forgotten. Many of us in the family learned the meaning of work at the restaurant. We fed many students, professors and families until 1976 when a fire destroyed the business. Service with a Smile was written in Italian on every menu. Each of us take pride in being remembered. thank you, John
By John Simeone on 01/18/2007 at 1:12:04
Re: 40 years of Boston (Phoenix) food
My father was a Doc at McLean's Hosp. in the 1960's and '70's and couldn't boil an egg to save himself.  Utterly incapable of feeding himself he sought out all of the serious Boston eateries in the late 50's and early 60's when he was a med student, intern and resident.  Ken's, Elsies Delicatessen, and Simeone's.  Some of my earliest and most fond memories are of Simeone's.  I remember my dad being greeted with a "Hello nice to see you again!" as we walked in.  I remember the booths, the red and white gingham table cloths, the jukeboxes, murals of Venice and sights of Italy. the super chlorinated Cambridge water--we drank Cokes always, but most of all I remember the pizza.  Simeone's made the Platonic ideal of pizza.  Thin crust, but not anorexic like some of the trendy pizza places today. Delicate and satisfying.  Parmesan in with the mozzarella, loads of oregano in the sauce, olive oil. 
I remember very clearly when Simeone's burned down.  I remember exactly where I was when we heard.  My sisters and my mom, we all cried like babies--we loved that place to much.  My father had already passed away by that point. I have no doubt he would have shed a tear as well. When I was in high school, I discovered Galleria Umberto's in the North End, and as good as they are/were, which is to say outstanding, they still are not as good as Simeone's.
 I have lived in NY State for most of my adult life, and for years I was obsessed with finding a pie that comes close to Simeone's.  I've spent countless hours searching for an establishment here in Rochester that comes close.  When I lived in NYC just weeks before I moved up here, I found a place on the Upper West Side that made a perfect pie--I couldn't have told it apart from Simeone's.  But that is the only one I've ever found.  Two local places come close for pizza, about 90%, but it's not quite the same, and neither is particularly family friendly.  

As a dad now, I've been looking for a place that has even a fraction of the friendly atmosphere and incredible food of Simeone's.  My quest so far has been a dismal failure, but we keep searching.  We keep trying.   Dave in Rochester, NY
By Pie Obsessed on 07/13/2008 at 12:56:52

Best Music Poll 2009 winners
Today's Event Picks
Share this entry with Delicious
  •   TAJINE  |  August 26, 2009
    With visions of spices of the souk, we are apt to imagine that Moroccan food is as spicy as that of Mexico or Ethiopia.
  •   ROWES WHARF SEA GRILLE  |  August 19, 2009
    It's hard to believe Daniel Bruce has been executive chef at the Boston Harbor Hotel for 20 years, outlasting the managers that hired him and both of his original restaurants in these waterfront digs.
  •   PAZZO  |  August 12, 2009
  •   TERANGA  |  July 29, 2009
    Teranga is Boston's first serious Senegalese restaurant, but belongs more in the upscale-import category with the Helmand, Lala Rokh, and Orinoco than with typical immigrant restaurants. It's a pleasant and beautifully decorated bistro where diners mingle and have a good time.
  •   THE FRIENDLY TOAST  |  July 22, 2009
    There was some in-office debate about reviewing the Friendly Toast in our "On the Cheap" column. After all, its menu of diner favorites, retro-'50s filler-uppers, and contemporary vegetarian options are pretty inexpensive. And their motto is "Great Food. Cheap."

 See all articles by: ROBERT NADEAU

RSS Feed of for the most popular articles
 Most Viewed   Most Emailed 

  |  Sign In  |  Register
Phoenix Media/Communications Group:
Copyright © 2009 The Phoenix Media/Communications Group